The First Owner’s Reference

Chapter 05 Guest opinion

In conversation with Benjamin Maltby

Benjamin Maltby is a partner at Keystone Law, General Secretary of The Owners Club, and a barrister, formerly of Ince & Co, who advises owners, yards and finance providers on superyacht construction, refit, purchase and sale, and finance. Keystone provides legal services discussed in this chapter. We put three questions to him on the new build contract: the yard’s in-house template, the refund guarantee when a yard’s finances change mid-build, and title during construction. His answers are published as given, lightly edited for typography. They are not legal or tax advice.

Benjamin Maltby

In conversation with

Benjamin Maltby

Partner, Keystone Law; General Secretary, The Owners Club Barrister; superyacht construction, refit, sale and purchase, and finance

LinkedIn
01

The major European yards do not contract on the maritime industry standard SAJ or NEWBUILDCON terms. They all have in-house templates drafted by their own counsel, often with English law and London arbitration attached. When a first-time buyer’s team receives that first draft, which side carries most of the risk, and which clauses do you open first?

Major European yards use their own templates. These are drafted by the yard’s counsel for the yard’s benefit. English law and London arbitration are often chosen, as English law is predictable. Arbitration awards can be easier to enforce than court judgments. Further, arbitration is private while court proceedings are public and can attract considerable media attention.

A first draft is likely to place most risk on the buyer. It usually offers wide rights for the yard to change the specification and the delivery date. It offers narrow rights for the buyer to reject the vessel or terminate. It typically allows liquidated damages for delay only at low rates and capped at a modest total. It can limit liability for defects to a short warranty period.

Negotiation is usually possible on major points, but yards expect to hold their position on the core structure, and buyers do better by selecting a few essential changes than by redrafting everything.

02

Refund guarantees are meant to secure the stage payments a buyer pays forward. Nobiskrug in 2024 and Italian Sea Group in 2026 have shown what happens when a yard’s financial condition changes mid-build. In practice, how much protection does a refund guarantee give, what separates a reliable one from a weak one, and what should be agreed at heads of terms about a distressed-yard scenario before it arises?

A refund guarantee is a promise from a bank or insurer to repay the buyer’s stage payments if the yard fails to deliver and the buyer terminates under the contract. It is a separate contract between the guarantor and the buyer, and the guarantor’s obligation is independent of any dispute between buyer and yard. It protects the buyer against the yard’s insolvency in a way that a claim against the yard cannot, because an insolvent yard cannot pay.

The protection has limits. The guarantee covers only the sums actually paid, not the buyer’s wider losses, such as lost use, financing costs and expenditure on owner-supplied items. It responds only if its conditions are met. These usually include a valid termination under the contract, a written demand within a time limit, and presentation of specified documents. A guarantor may delay or contest the claim if the demand is defective. A guarantee is worth only as much as the guarantor, so the credit quality of the issuer matters.

A reliable guarantee has several features. It is issued by a bank of high credit standing, preferably one that is independent of the yard and its group. It is on-demand, which means the guarantor pays on a written demand without investigating the dispute. It covers all instalments, with interest. It has a long enough validity period, usually running until delivery plus a margin.

The buyer should secure a right to obtain information on the yard’s financial condition at set intervals, and a right to suspend payments if specific warning signs appear, such as missed supplier payments, a rating downgrade, a covenant breach or a shareholder change. The buyer should also agree step-in rights, allowing the buyer to take over the unfinished hull, materials and design files and complete the vessel elsewhere. These points are far easier to agree before the contract is signed than after the first problem appears.

A guarantee is worth only as much as the guarantor, so the credit quality of the issuer matters.

03

Title during construction. Some yards retain title until delivery; others pass it progressively as stages are paid. For an owner who has paid 60 percent of the contract price forward, what does each position mean if the yard becomes insolvent, and what security would you want in place alongside it?

Title decides who owns the unfinished vessel and materials if the yard fails. Under a retention of title model, the yard owns the vessel until delivery, and the buyer holds only a contractual right to receive it. Under a progressive transfer model, title passes to the buyer as each stage is paid or as materials are identified and incorporated.

For a buyer who has paid 60 percent of the price, the two positions differ sharply. If the yard keeps title and becomes insolvent, the unfinished vessel is part of the yard’s estate. The buyer is an unsecured creditor, and the buyer’s money is in the hull, which the insolvency officeholder controls and may sell to repay all creditors. The buyer’s main recourse is the refund guarantee. The buyer has no right to remove the vessel.

If title has passed progressively, the buyer owns the hull and materials paid for, at least in principle. The buyer may then argue that these assets are outside the insolvency estate, and may seek to take them or have them completed by another yard. This position is stronger on paper than in practice. Title may be hard to prove because materials are not marked, are mixed with others or are held by suppliers who retain their own title. The insolvency law of the yard’s country may not respect the transfer. The buyer may lack physical access to the site, and the officeholder may refuse to release the vessel, relying on a lien or on the need to preserve the estate. Court action to recover assets takes time, and a half-built vessel loses value.

Security should therefore accompany either model. The refund guarantee should cover all payments, including the 60 percent paid. If title has passed progressively, the contract should require the yard to mark and identify the vessel and materials, to keep them separately where possible, to give the buyer inspection rights, and to insure them with the buyer named as insured. The contract should include a clear statement that the yard holds the assets for the buyer and a right of entry and removal on insolvency or default. The buyer should obtain a local-law opinion on whether the transfer of title will be recognised in the yard’s jurisdiction.

If the yard keeps title and becomes insolvent, the unfinished vessel is part of the yard’s estate. The buyer is an unsecured creditor.

Answers given by Benjamin Maltby, Partner, Keystone Law; General Secretary, The Owners Club; Barrister; superyacht construction, refit, sale and purchase, and finance. Lightly edited for typography, and approved by the contributor before publication.